COVID-19 Update: W.B. Goodnow Agency continues to follow the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's (CDC) guidelines to ensure that our office is as safe and healthy as possible. While in our office, please social distance and wear a mask at all times. Thank you!

car in front of home

Home, Auto, Renters, and Small Business Insurance

As an independent insurance agency, we have a wide variety of insurance carriers for home, auto, renters, and small business insurance.

Multiple carriers allow us to offer you the most competitive rates and provide a customized insurance plan to ensure we match you with the company that best meets your needs.

Fill out this form for a quote
90+ Years of Experience

With decades of experience, we are also able to answer any simple or complicated insurance questions. It is our goal to provide you with better coverage at lower rates and quality service throughout your plan. At the W.B. Goodnow Agency, we are friendly, professional, experienced and right down the street!

Goodnow Insurance Employees in Winthrop NY

Trusted Choice® agencies are dedicated to you and are committed to treating you as a person, not a policy. All Trusted Choice® agencies agree to adhere to a Pledge of Performance, designed to assure quality service that enables them to offer you competitive pricing, a broad choice of products, and valuable advocacy.

Mark Goodnow at desk with child
Multiple carriers

Independent insurance agencies have multiple carriers, which means customers get competitive insurance quotes from different vendors and great bundles all under one roof.

Insurance Claims

Please contact us directly for assistance filing a claim, or submit claims directly with your carrier.

Goodnow Insurance employee at desk

Contact Us

Physical Address

1 Cemetery Street

Winthrop, NY 13697 (map)

Mailing Address

PO Box 266

Winthrop, NY 13697

For any questions, please call (315) 389-5145 or fill out the form below.

Please call us directly to make policy changes. Changes cannot be made via email or our website. Thank you.


Physical Address

1 Cemetery St, Winthrop, NY 13697 (map)


Mailing Address

PO Box 266, Winthrop, NY 13697

Phone: (315) 389-5145

Fax: (315) 389-5146

Hours: Monday - Friday 8:30 AM to 4:30 PM

  • Facebook - Black Circle