Claims Contact Information

Customers can contact us directly for assistance filing a claim, or in many cases, submit claims directly with a carrier. The insurance carriers below have direct contact options.

Allstate

Website: Claims

Claims Phone: (800) 366-3495

Progressive

Website: Claims

Claims Phone: (800) 776-4737

Erie & Niagara

Website: Claims

Claims Phone: (800) 234-9876

McNeil & Co

Website: Claims

Claims Phone: (800) 822-3747

Old Dominion

Website: Claims

Claims Phone: (877) 425-2467

VFIS

Website: Claims

Claims Phone: (800) 233-1957

National Grange

Website: Claims

Claims Phone: (877) 425-2467

Otsego Mutual

Website: Claims

Claims Phone: (607) 965-8211